top of page

Challenge to San Francisco's Noncitizen Voting Law Raises Concerns about Dilution of Minority Voting

Updated: May 10, 2023

The right to vote is a fundamental aspect of democracy, and it has long been recognized as a cornerstone of citizenship in the United States. However, a recent challenge to San Francisco's law allowing noncitizens to vote in school board elections has raised concerns about the dilution of voting strength among minority groups, particularly Black citizens.

The Lex Rex Institute is excited to work with J. Christian Adams and the Public Interest Legal Foundation in challenging this law. The Public Interest Legal Foundation is a non-profit law firm dedicated to protecting election integrity and fighting against voter fraud. The collaboration between these organizations highlights the importance of protecting the integrity of the election process and preserving the fundamental right to vote for citizens of the United States.

In their brief on behalf of J. Kenneth Blackwell argues that San Francisco's noncitizen voter program undermines the very concept of citizenship by extending voting rights to individuals who are not citizens of the United States. It is argued that this dilutes the voting strength of minority groups, particularly Black citizens, who have struggled for over a century and a half to secure the right to vote.

The case is important because it raises questions about the definition and meaning of citizenship and the potential impact of extending voting rights to non-citizens. While the program in San Francisco is limited to school board elections, it could set a precedent for further extension of voting rights to non-citizens in other elections, which could have a significant impact on the political landscape and representation of various groups.

Moreover, Blackwell's argument highlights the historical use of the noncitizen Latino population in redistricting in California, which has resulted in the shift of political power from Black citizens to Latino noncitizens. This could further undermine the political strength of minority groups and lead to a dilution of their voting power, particularly in democratic primary elections.

The case also highlights the ongoing struggle of Black Americans for voting rights, which has spanned over a century and a half. It underscores the importance of protecting and preserving the right to vote, particularly for minority groups who have historically been disenfranchised and marginalized.

Overall, the brief filed by J. Kenneth Blackwell underscores the potential negative impact of San Francisco's noncitizen voter program on minority groups' voting strength and highlights the importance of protecting the right to vote and preserving the integrity of citizenship in the United States.

11 views0 comments


bottom of page